The Good, the Bad, the Unfinished
Produced using AI for “Talking Transportation” – November
2026. All opinions are those of Claude
AI.
Original query:
“Itemize long promised studies by the Connecticut Department of
Transportation seen over the last 15 years … comparing what was promised as a
goal and what was delivered in terms of change to the better… which ones failed
and which one still have not finished their work.
Scorecard
|
Project |
First promised |
Promised outcome |
Where It Stands Now |
Verdict |
|
Hartford Line |
2004 study |
New commuter service, New Haven–Springfield |
Running since June 2018; 22 weekday round trips |
Good |
|
Waterbury Branch |
2010 study |
Better service, accessible stations |
Signals and sidings by 2022; station rebuilds through 2028 |
Good, late |
|
Let's Go CT |
2015 |
$100B, 30-year rebuild |
Never funded |
Bad |
|
Highway tolls |
2009 onward |
~$1B a year in revenue |
Abandoned; truck fee budgeted at ~$62M |
Bad |
|
Danbury electrification |
2006 study |
Electric service to Danbury |
Still diesel |
Bad |
|
Barnum Station in Bridgeport |
2013–2014 |
Opening by 2018, then 2021 |
Still "planned" |
Bad |
|
I-84 Hartford viaduct |
~2006 |
Replace the viaduct |
Re-studied; federal funding dashboard says cancelled |
Unfinished |
|
Route 7/15 interchange |
2005 construction |
Full interchange |
Construction may start 2027 |
Unfinished |
|
Walk Bridge |
2023 groundbreaking |
Done by 2029 |
Now 2031; grant money runs to 2032 |
Unfinished |
|
30-30-30 / TIME for CT |
2019 |
10 min saved by 2022, 25 by 2035 |
Replaced by TIME-1, target 2035 |
Unfinished |
|
Electrification study of branch lines |
2023 |
Report by end of 2025 |
"Nearing completion" |
Unfinished |
|
Hartford Line additional stations |
2004 |
Enfield, West Hartford, Newington, North Haven |
Enfield opens 2030; others unfunded |
Unfinished |
The good: delivered, if late
Hartford Line. Service launched June 16, 2018, more
than doubling trips in the corridor. It now runs 22 weekday round trips on top
of Amtrak, and had fully recovered pre-pandemic ridership by 2024. The one
genuine success. (CTDOT,
Hartford
Business)
Waterbury Branch. A 2010 CTDOT study identified
fixes. Then nearly a decade passed before real money arrived. New signals and
passing sidings let CTDOT add seven trips in summer 2022. All six stations are
being rebuilt from 2025 to 2028 for about $193 million, with buses replacing
trains July 2026 to May 2027. Good outcome, glacial pace. (NVCOG,
Metro
Magazine)
The bad: shelved or failed
Let's Go CT (2015). Governor Malloy proposed a
30-year, $100 billion program without saying how to pay for it. His own finance
panel found more than $40 billion in options in January 2016. None stuck. (Bond
Buyer, CT Mirror)
Highway tolls. The state spent over $20 million on
CDM Smith and Cambridge Systematics studies since 2009, plus a $10 million
study approved in 2018. The 2018 report
alone cost $2,035,000, about $23,391 a page. It proposed 82 gantries raising
roughly $1 billion a year. Governor Lamont dropped tolls for a truck Highway
Use Fee that DRS said would raise about $90 million a year. The official
forecast: $60.8 million in FY2025, $61.7 million in FY2026. (CT
Senate GOP, Yankee Institute,
News
12, OFA)
Danbury Branch electrification. Phase I wrapped in
2006; Phase II began November 2007 and ended with a final report in 2016. In
2006, electrifying South Norwalk to Danbury was pegged at $37 million, $127
million with new equipment. Never built. Still diesel. (CTDOT,
Phase II
site, Phase
I report)
Barnum Station, Bridgeport. Bridgeport Mayor Finch
hoped it would be built by 2018. By 2018
the target was 2021, at $300 million. It
remains a “planned station”. (News
12, CT
Post, Wikipedia)
The unfinished: still studying, still building
I-84 Hartford viaduct. Planning began about two
decades ago. In 2016 CTDOT settled on a lowered highway. In 2019 it pulled the
I-84 study and swapped in a three-year regional mobility study. That report
landed in late 2023; its big pieces still face state and federal environmental
review. The federal permitting dashboard now lists the I-84 Hartford Project as
cancelled. Meanwhile the old viaduct gets bridge rehab through July 2027. (CT
Mirror, Hartford
Business, AASHTO
Journal, Permitting
Dashboard, CTDOT)
Route 7/Merritt Parkway interchange, Norwalk.
Construction began in 2005, was stopped by a lawsuit, and was cancelled in
2006. A new study followed, then a May 2023 environmental assessment. The $175
million project may start in 2027. Twenty-two years from first shovel to
second. (Project history, EA,
CT
Construction Digest)
Walk Bridge, Norwalk. At the May 2023 groundbreaking,
completion was expected in 2029. CTDOT's FAQ now says 2031. The federal grant's
end date moved from 2030 to 2032, and obligations rose 37% to $947 million. (Mass
Transit, Walk Bridge FAQ, HigherGov)
30-30-30 / TIME for CT. Lamont's 2019 pledge became
an $8–$10 billion plan promising 10 minutes saved by 2022 and 25 by 2035. The
2022 milestone came and went. Its successor, TIME-1 ($1.6 billion, 90 mph),
targets 2035 and starts with a 3-mile Bridgeport–Stratford stretch. (CTDOT
TIME for CT)
Electrification study (Hartford, Danbury, Waterbury
lines). Launched August 2023 with a promised finish by end of 2025. CRCOG's
June 2026 report says it is "nearing completion." No report yet. (CTDOT,
CRCOG)
Hartford Line additional stations. Enfield was in a
2004 recommended action. It broke ground Oct. 28, 2026, with completion in fall
2030. Twenty-six years. West Hartford
sits at 30% design with no construction money; Newington has concept drawings.
(Wikipedia,
Hartford
Business, CRCOG)
The pattern
Studies finish on time far more often than projects do.
When a study's answer is expensive, the fix is usually another study. The
deadlines that slip are the ones riders and drivers actually feel.
Sources for details
•
CTDOT:
Hartford Line Regional Vision
•
Hartford
Business: Enfield station groundbreaking
•
CRCOG:
Hartford Line overview, June 2026
•
NVCOG:
Waterbury Line Improvement Strategy
•
Metro
Magazine: Waterbury Line station upgrades
•
CT Mirror:
Transportation finance panel
•
Yankee
Institute: Cost of 2018 tolls study
•
OFA:
Consensus Revenue Estimates, Nov. 2024
•
CTDOT:
Danbury Branch Electrification Study
•
Danbury Branch
Phase II site
•
Danbury
Phase I Final Report
•
News
12: Bridgeport to design second station
•
CT
Post: Barnum Station expectations
•
CT
Mirror: Hartford highway realignment
•
Hartford
Business: Elevated option ruled out
•
AASHTO
Journal: Greater Hartford Mobility Study
•
Federal
Permitting Dashboard: I-84 Hartford Project
•
CTDOT:
I-84 Sigourney Street bridge rehab
•
Route
7/15 Environmental Assessment, May 2023
•
CT
Construction Digest: Route 7/15 timing
•
Mass
Transit: Walk Bridge construction begins
No comments:
Post a Comment