November 08, 2013

"Slow Orders" for Metro-North

No, it’s not your imagination.  Service is getting even worse on Metro-North. And there’s no sign of short-term improvements.
This has been a terrible year for Metro-North and its 120,000 daily riders in Connecticut:  the May derailment / collision, the death of a track worker and the September “meltdown” because of a failed Con Ed feeder.  But the repercussions of these problems still affect us, months later.
Trains are late on a daily basis, even after the railroad adjusted the timetable in August to reflect longer running times.  What used to be a 48 minute ride from Stamford to GCT is now scheduled for 55 to 60 minutes.  But in reality, with delays, it takes more than an hour most days.
Why?  Because of “slow orders”.
After the May derailments, Metro-North brought in some high-tech rail scanning equipment and checked out every inch of track in the system.  Of immediate concern were the below-grade tracks in the Bronx, long subject to flooding.
Concrete ties installed between 1990 and ’96 needed to be replaced due to deterioration.  Ties and fencing were also replaced in a job so large that, at times, three of the four tracks were taken out of service.
Admittedly, it’s hard to run the busiest commuter railroad in the US with 75% of your tracks out of service, but the work was necessary and commuters were asked to be patient.  At last report, the Bronx work was 80% completed.
So that means train schedules will soon return to “normal”?  Sorry, but no.
It turns out that the Bronx is just one of the causes of the current delays, something Metro-North didn’t tell us.
With new timetables coming out on November 17th, some train runs may be improved by a minute (yes, 60 seconds), at best. It seems that all those high-tech track inspections since May turned up many spots where work is needed.  And until that work can be completed, the trains running over those tracks are operating under system-wide “slow orders”, in effect cutting their speeds from 85 or 90 mph to an average of 60 mph.  Don’t believe me?  Fire up your smart phone’s GPS next ride and see for yourself.
The railroad still blames daily delays on the work in the Bronx and wet leaves, but the truth is far worse.  At recent NTSB hearings on the May derailment, Metro-North admitted they are far behind on track maintenance, inspections and repairs in Connecticut but couldn’t explain why.  Until the tracks are fixed, trains won’t be allowed to run at full speed.
One thing they did acknowledge to investigators is that they don’t have the experienced staff to do the needed welding and repair work, having lost so many veteran workers in recent months to retirement.
The slow orders make sense.  Safety should always come first.  But why can’t railroad executives be honest with us about why we are suffering with these delays, how long they will last and what they are doing to minimize the disruption to our daily commutes?  Remember:  winter is coming, adding another layer of misery and delays to our commutes.

Sadly, my mantra from five years ago has proven correct:  Things are going to get a lot worse on Metro-North before they get better.


Unknown said...

I can't wait to see the performance reports. If it indicates that the New Haven line was anything north of 60% on time - you know the whole thing is a farce.

LBM said...

This blog sums it up...I am simply tired of the excuses. Unfortunately MTA will not get the picture until there is a mass exodus and revenues are at stake and there is no viable alternative.

Unknown said...

Thanks Jim, I was going to ask you about the delays... the commute is getting longer every day but it still does not justify driving into NYC every day. Thanks for keeping us informed.
Debbie E.

Bruce Beckett said...

At last, the real reasons behind our daily delays are revealed. Why are the newspapers and media outlets not picking up on this story? Why are Metro-North not coming clean with their long-suffering customers? It's an absolute disgrace.

NinaGib said...

Hi Jim. Im new to your blog but happy to have found it. I am so fed up with the daily delays that i have saved every text from mnr for over 2 months. I would love to send this list of delays/excuses to someone or some entity to get a higher profile of the issues and greater transparency. As you noted "back to normal" is not so...


How’s this for a double-whammy?  CDOT is proposing a cut in train and bus service while also raising fares… just as I predicted months ago ....